Supervisors Ratify Pension Director Contract Worth More Than Five Times the County's Median Income

Mendocino County supervisors ratified a new contract for the retirement system's executive director — $357,000 in total compensation, more than five times the county's median household income.

The brick rotunda and covered entrance of the Administration Center under a cloudy sky
The Mendocino County Administration Center in Ukiah, where the Board of Supervisors meets. (MendoLocal.News CC BY 4.0)


UKIAH, Calif. — The Mendocino County Board of Supervisors on Nov. 17 ratified a new three-year employment contract for Doris Rentschler as executive director of the Mendocino County Employees' Retirement Association, setting her base salary at $210,000 and total compensation at $357,000 beginning in December. Rentschler also receives 3% cost-of-living increases in 2027 and 2028 that return to the board for review if inflation comes in below that mark.

A county employee since June 2020, Rentschler has effectively doubled her compensation over that span, from $144,391 in total pay and benefits in that partial first year to $294,920 in 2025, according to Transparent California. Her new total compensation is more than five times Mendocino County's median household income of roughly $68,000, according to U.S. Census Bureau estimates.

Supervisor John Haschak, the board's representative on the MCERA board and a member of the ad hoc committee that negotiated the deal, said the aim was to bring the director's pay in line with comparable positions. "The idea was to get the executive director up to ... the comparable level, and we've done that with some of our executive-level staff," he said, calling the result "a fair and just negotiated salary." Alex Land, chair of the MCERA Board of Trustees, told supervisors the contract "puts us in a reasonable and a respectable distance from the other executive directors." The board approved it unanimously.

You Read Our Stories. Please Help Fund Our Newsroom.

MendoLocal.News was created by locals for locals. We pay attention and dig deeper and we distribute for free. With your support, we can keep going.

3× Give today and donors will triple your gift.
Fund Our Newsroom

The vote came as the retirement system's finances have strengthened. In his supervisor's report, Haschak said MCERA's funded ratio measured against market value had climbed from 79.6% to 90.3% over the past year, with $25.6 million in investment gains and an additional $93.5 million in deferred market gains to be recognized over four years.

Supervisors also authorized Sheriff Matt Kendall to pursue a new records system for his department, approving the use of up to $275,000 from the county's General Fund Infrastructure and Systems Reserve toward an agreement with Sun Ridge Systems Inc. The quoted price for the RIMS (Records Information Management System) platform is $1,980,088, and the board authorized the sheriff to sign a contract up to 10% above that figure, covering patrol, dispatch, and jail operations through June 30, 2032.

According to the sheriff's office, the new software can cut the time deputies spend on paperwork and let the office share reports and investigations with neighboring agencies that use the same platform. Kendall told the board of supervisors the office would keep seeking grant funding to offset the cost and warned that pending state legislation to tax computer software could add unbudgeted expense across county departments.

"I'll continue to work on trying to keep the wolf away from the door on some of these things," Kendall said. "But we have to move forward on this." Supervisor Madeline Cline thanked him for the explanation and his commitment to pursue grants, and the board approved the item unanimously.

The board split 4-1 over a direction item from Haschak and Supervisor Ted Williams asking staff to work with the cities of Ukiah, Willits, Fort Bragg, and Point Arena toward amending the county's Master Tax Sharing Agreement, the framework that governs annexation negotiations. The item followed a failed Ukiah annexation bid that had produced pointed disputes over who would bear the financial impact.

"Although some are celebrating that the annexation didn't go through, together we haven't actually solved any of the major problems," Williams said. "Annexation is a tool to reach a goal." He said he wanted to avoid a repeat of the earlier standoff: "We can't have a repeat of what we had where there's arguments of money grabs. ... We're kind of insane if we go down that same path, thinking we're going to get a different outcome next time."

Chief Executive Officer Sara Pierce told the board that all four cities had asked to pause the conversation until their newly elected councils are seated and can form ad hoc committees. She said Ukiah was not interested in separate talks unless every city took part. The motion carried with Chair Bernie Norvell dissenting.

Two residents used the public-comment period to press the board on issues not on the agenda. Jacob Redding presented a petition titled "A Lawful Place to Be," describing a travel trailer that moved from an encampment near Kuki Lane to North Bush Street on Nov. 10 after sheriff's deputies instructed its occupants to relocate.

"The immediate complaints may have been resolved, but where did those people go?" he asked.

Redding asked the board to direct staff to study whether existing homelessness funds or county property could support a lawful, managed place for people living in vehicles. Supervisor Mo Mulheren said the county's new CORE 2.0 program is designed to address that gap.

Annemarie Weibel called in to object to a T-Mobile permit the Planning Commission approved Nov. 5 to extend an existing cell tower on Navarro Ridge near Albion by 22 feet, with no expiration date. She said the county's wireless guidelines, last updated in 2015, do not account for 5G technology, and urged the board to rewrite them, pointing to a Tahoe Regional Planning Agency ordinance restricting plastic "monopine" tower disguises, which she said shed lead and microplastics into drinking water.

Weibel cited a National Toxicology Program study that she said found "clear evidence of cancer and DNA damage" from electromagnetic-field exposure, and said the World Health Organization's International Agency for Research on Cancer has classified such fields as possible carcinogens, calling them harmful "to people, animals and plants." She also noted that the tower sits next to a children's playground. "Please update these. ... They are completely outdated," she said.