LaFever Case Heads to Resolution Dec. 7 As Attorneys Describe a Deal in the Works

Attorneys in former Ukiah High teacher Matthew LaFever's misdemeanor case told a judge they expect to present a negotiated resolution Dec. 7.

A concrete wall with purple "UKIAH HIGH SCHOOL" lettering below yellow ginkgo trees and painted murals on a school building.
Ukiah High School, where Matthew LaFever taught journalism part time before he was placed on leave in October 2025. (MendoLocal.News CC BY 4.0)

UKIAH, Calif. — Attorneys in the misdemeanor case against Matthew LaFever, the former Ukiah High School journalism teacher who published the now-shuttered news site MendoFever, told a judge Thursday they are close to a plea deal. They asked for more time to work out how it would apply to a defendant who lives out of state.

Defense attorney Orchid Vaghti told Mendocino County Superior Court Judge Charlotte Scott that the parties were trying to accommodate out-of-state residency. She also referred to Penal Code section 290, California's sex-offender registration law. A conviction under the statute LaFever is charged with requires registration under that law.

Vaghti, with Deputy District Attorney Robert J. Waner present for the People, asked to return Dec. 7 or 8. She said she planned to appear for LaFever under Penal Code section 977, which lets a misdemeanor defendant appear through counsel. She said he would come to court if necessary but that she would like to avoid that. Scott set the case for Dec. 7 at 9 a.m.

LaFever, 38, faces a single misdemeanor count of annoying or molesting a child under 18 (Penal Code section 647.6(a)(1)). He was arrested by Ukiah police in November 2025, charged in April 2026, and has pleaded not guilty. The terms of any agreement have not been stated in court, and no new plea has been entered.

MendoLocal.News previously reported that the parties had set Thursday's hearing for a possible disposition after both sides received outstanding discovery. Because LaFever was a working journalist, the court appointed a special master to screen material seized from his devices for press-protected newsgathering information, and District Attorney David Eyster recused himself.

You Read Our Stories. Please Help Fund Our Newsroom.

MendoLocal.News was created by locals for locals. We pay attention and dig deeper and we distribute for free. With your support, we can keep going.

3× Give today and donors will triple your gift.
Fund Our Newsroom